MerQuR+Statistics Glossary

Statistics Glossary → QIC and QICu criteria

QIC and QICu criteriaconcept

Quasi-likelihood-based model selection criteria used in generalized estimating equations (GEE) in place of the AIC, since no full likelihood is defined there.

GEE specifies only the mean structure and a working correlation matrix; it does not build a full probability model, so neither the likelihood nor the AIC can be computed. Pan (2001) proposed the criterion QIC = −2·QL + 2·tr(Ω_I·V_R), using the quasi-likelihood (QL) under independence. Here Ω_I is the model-based information matrix under independence and V_R is the robust (sandwich) covariance matrix. The second term plays the role of the 2p penalty in the AIC.

QIC is used to compare different working correlation structures (independence, exchangeable, AR(1), unstructured) for the same mean model, with smaller values preferred. QICu takes the penalty simply as 2p and is suited to comparing different sets of predictors under the same correlation structure. Both are rough guides: when the differences are small, a theoretically sensible and interpretable structure should be chosen. Thanks to sandwich standard errors, GEE coefficients remain consistent even if the correlation structure is misspecified; the right structure only improves efficiency.

An everyday example

In a diet study, patients' weight is measured every month for 6 months. The researcher wants to choose between an exchangeable correlation (any two measurements equally related) and an AR(1) correlation (nearby months more related). The QIC values are 412 and 398, suggesting that the AR(1) structure, in which consecutive measurements are more strongly related, fits the data better.

In MerQur

In generalized estimating equations, the 'QIC / QICu' output is computed with Pan's (2001) formula and is used to choose the working correlation structure.

Analyses where this concept appears

Generalized Estimating Equations (GEE)

Related concepts

Information criteria (AIC, AICc, BIC)Covariance (correlation) structure (UN, VC, AR(1), exchangeable)